Thunder Achievers better than Dirty Projectors?
A bunch of us went and saw Dirty Projectors at the Fillmore on Saturday night. They are truly impressive. It’s actually hard to believe that a band playing rock and roll (more or less) can be so proficient, so cerebral, and so elegantly fractured in their approach. In 20th-21st century pop music, Dirty Projectors have to be one of the artiest ensembles to have won some love in the mainstream. I’m actually surprised so many casual music listeners like them, as they are, no doubt about it, a difficult band. And as someone who digs free jazz and beard-stroking instrumental “post-rock,” I definitely appreciate Dirty Projectors, especially their last album, Bitte Orca, which seemed to crystallize a lot of what they’ve been going for in previous albums.
So, the astonishing, laser-guided, often strident harmonies; the crazily but precisely out-of-time guitar solos; the ridiculously tight rhythm section—seeing Dirty Projectors live confirms their skill. They can pull all of it off. The song forms themselves are complex enough to cause fits, never mind that they are performed flawlessly.
But for all this, I found myself strangely unmoved. It’s strange to see a band filtering so much Afro beat/Afro pop through its own sensibility, and at the same time, stripping that tradition of all of its pulse and groove. This is deliberate, of course. Just like Talking Heads before them, Dirty Projectors are working with an abstracted and an intellectualized hybrid of rock and Afro beat. There is a strict discipline in this music, and it leans strongly in the direction of the austere and the anti-pop. As I do Talking Heads, I find Dirty Projectors a little harmonically static or un-involving. There are hooks to be found, but they are not the kind to stir you or set your foot tapping. True, there are some catchy and beautiful numbers on Bitte Orca, but they are outweighed by songs which (I think) are purposefully grating or hard to sing in the shower.
Thunder Achievers, on the other hand, are effortlessly grating, stupid almost beyond reproach, and write songs that could be played by children, rather untalented children at that.



